I did it!...and I LOVE my principal for letting me do it. I got rid of my student desks in my third grade classroom. Our school maintenance supervisor is awesome, too, for taking them OUT with approximately 10 weeks left in the school year. It is a work in progress and I will post some "in progress" photos next week. Check out the bottom of this post for photos of classrooms that have also gone "Deskless" that served as my inspiration. Here is one of them:
|
Teacher Holly Albrecht |
So why now?
First, I need explain
what I am NOT doing:
1. I am
not doing this to be "progressive." I'm not a fan of extremes. I've been a principal of a 1-1 learning environment, built a middle school and picked out all of the furniture for our new "21st Century" building, and know that there is a philosophy out there that we all need to go to extremes for the sake of being "progressive." Great teaching is just great teaching...everything else is just objects and tools. Believe me. I've been there, done that, and the best tools and prettiest buildings are not a guarantee for the best learning.
2. I am
not doing this to be perfectly organized. In fact, I am messy and will never win the golden dustpan award. It will never change. Active learning is messy and wonderful.
3. I am
not doing this to get attention. I blog to help us teach humans. It is hard, rewarding, and complicated...I am far from perfect. If I think of something that may help other teachers teach human beings I will share the good, the bad, and the ugly. If it is an epic fail, I will admit it so others don't do what I did.
Now...why
AM I doing this? Here are the top reasons in no particular order (except for #11 which is the most important...)
1.
Student Engagement - Keeping attention. I was tired of students messing with stuff in their desks and it was keeping them preoccupied. I tried everything. We cleared them all out and had tubs for materials but all the clutter crept back in.
I even tried turning the desks around so the "holes" were not visible, but there was an annoying bar across the back that didn't allow for leg room. How could I create a space where the temptation to "fiddle" was controlled? "One two, Eyes on Me..." "one, two, eyes on you..." can only be stated so many times before a migraine sets in.
2.
Space confinement. No matter how many different ways we arranged our desks, they took up too much learning space. I got rid of my teacher desk before the school year and use my kidney shaped table, but even so, the student desks took up a lot of the room. This limited options for work areas and movement.
3.
Student input I asked the students how they learned best. Sitting in a desk was not the preferred method. The look on their faces was priceless when I announced that we were going to get rid of the desks. I think they didn't believe me. Two of them brought in their grandmas to see it this morning because they were so excited...talk about a goose bump moment!
4.
Thinking about my own learning preference. Most adults don't like to sit in a confined desk, why would our students? If you are lucky enough to attend educational conferences, think about how much torture it is to sit still period after period during sessions. The speaker and content may be the best thing you have ever heard, yet sitting still for extended periods of time in one place sucks out most of the excitement.
5.
Student Achievement What we are doing isn't working. Our students are not performing up to their potential on assessments...both local and state. Why is that? I believe ALL kids can learn no matter what at high levels...it's just figuring out how each child "ticks" to make that happen. Could the classroom learning arrangement be crafted to spark deeper learning that will translate into results? This contradicts my point earlier about how objects and tools can't guarantee results, but it can spark better teaching and other ways of doing this if the space is different.
6.
Let Students Be Who They Are! Every classroom has sitters, talkers, movers, wanderers, and standers. When I surveyed my students, "who would prefer to still have a desk?"... It was extremely interesting to see my own predictions blown away...students that I
thought wanted a desk wanted to get
out of the desk.
How much instructional time do we waste every single day trying to get the wanderers to stop wandering, the standers to sit, the talkers to be quiet, and the sitters to do something? A classroom with a variety of learning spaces allows students to learn the way they learn best.
7.
Safety I'm being brutally honest...student desks can be tipped over, hide sharp objects and other goodies.When students have other learning spaces, they can't hide things we don't want them to have. Replacing desks with a couple of tables, some interesting chairs, and adding some floor space is much safer and allows the teacher some more control of what materials get in the students' hands.
8.
A Family Feel I want our classroom to feel like a family, and making the room look like a comfortable, safe place supports this goal. My goal is to mix in softer edges with the school industrial aspects.
9.
Flexibility This was an afterthought, not something I thought of before the desks were gone:
It is difficult to get substitutes in our building, and we often split classes. I realized that I won't have to grab additional chairs for the day. They can fit right in with everybody else and we won't be crowded! If I get a new student, they just fit right in where they want to go!
10.
It has Simplified Procedures Like #9, this was an afterthought. I have more instructional time at the end of the day because we are not stacking chairs or putting or taking things out of desks! It has simplified distribution of materials. Students MUST keep their things in the community areas/shelves/tubs and cannot keep them in their desks. No more hoarding. No more losing papers, books and work. Of course, somebody will lose something at some time, but it has taken away one of the obstacles to organization and student responsibility.
11.
I believe in a Passion-Driven Classroom The Most Important Reason for a Deskless Classroom!
In a passion-driven classroom, students have choice and are apprentice scientists, historians, mathematicians, writers and readers. There needs to be designated, purposeful areas where our students can practice their passions.
For example, this group of students has a particular passion for life science...and it happens to be
The Decorah Eagles...a live streaming video of an eagle's nest. A special area and procedure is in place to take "Science Lab Notes" about the nesting behaviors and other observations. We have a class lab notebook that rotates groups during Readers' Workshop. In order to take their best lab notes, they need to get close to the Promethean Board where the live stream video is projected.
We will see how this all works out. If it doesn't work or if I find that student learning is not improving, I will need to ask myself some more questions. If it is wildly successful, then I will share the experience and tips to make this all work. I am so blessed to have a principal that supports me in this effort and is willing to let me try for the sake of student learning!
Now for some links and photos of classrooms I found through my research. I have started a
Pinterest Board if you would like to see updates of added classrooms.
|
I cannot find the original source for this classroom. Please comment if you know or if this is your classroom so I can give it the correct credit it deserves. |